SURE: Articles from Past SURE Programs

Empathetic Allies or Callous Companions?
Susan Borja

Just about everyone has experienced a common embarrassment: You eat something not easily contained on a utensil, then carry on a conversation for any amount of time; only later to look in a mirror and realize you have been walking around with remnants of dessert on your face or that delicious spinach salad in your teeth. You were not saving it for later, rather are just an occasionally messy eater. Once the unsightly remnants are discovered, have you ever wondered just how long it was there and why no one told you? You may be able to predict who will and won't tell you based on the gender of the company you keep and just how empathetic the friends are. If going to lunch before or as part of an important interview or date, this may be especially important.

Recently, researchers at Emory University took on the daunting task of unraveling the mystery of seemingly cruel friends. They exposed themselves to embarrassment and ridicule as they themselves donned chocolate in the corner of the mouth and approached a variety of their own friends. Under the guise of finishing a last minute class assignment, the “messy eating” researchers visited friends with a questionnaire measuring emotional empathy to test if empathy was an underlying factor.

When Peter Suedfeld and his colleagues demonstrated that those with similar beliefs are more likely to help (1972) it still left the question of why some with similar beliefs simply don't. Few can argue against helping a friend when so little time and effort are required. Also, since friends are more likely to help if they will feel guilty not helping (Birkimer 1993), it is hard to believe that our friends so often don't tell us. No one could argue that saving a friend from potential embarrassment is useful and allowing such embarrassment of a friend would undoubtedly arouse some guilt in a friend.

Researchers believed notification was contingent on higher levels of emotional empathy and suspected that gender may create further divide amongst those who tell and those who do not. Indeed, those with the highest empathy scores were, in fact, the most likely to tell researchers there was food on their face. Females were more likely than males to tell researchers about the food on their face (1.179 times more likely). Not surprising given the previous results, males also had lower empathy scores overall.

The association supports the hypothesis that the more empathetic a person is, the more likely they are to tell you there is something unsightly on your face. This was true for both males and females, although females had higher empathy overall. Thus, those most likely to notify you that there is chocolate in the corner of your mouth or some spinach in your teeth are your most empathetic female girl friends. This doesn't bode well for a female on a first date with a new man or interview with a male boss. It might be best to keep a napkin and mirror handy.